The voices of business and the consumer have come together in a call for swift, bold action from the next government to address New Zealand’s failing energy market.
In an open letter released today, a coalition comprised of business associations, Consumer NZ, and independent energy companies urged the next Minister of Energy to commit to three policy measures:
- A bi-partisan, national energy strategy
- Long-Term Energy Supply Agreements (LTESAs) with independent energy projects, to unlock a wave of investment in new supply
- Separation of the generation and retail functions of the four gentailers, to drive competition in the retail market
The letter is the latest step in a campaign that the Auckland Business Chamber, together with the Northan Infrastructure Forum, has been leading for the last two years, aimed at policy changes that will help deliver affordable, abundant energy for Kiwi businesses and households.
Chamber CEO Simon Bridges says over most of the last decade, New Zealand’s energy market has become an inhibiter of growth and wellbeing, not an enabler.
“This is reflected in the surge in energy prices we have seen in recent years: residential prices have increased by 20% in the last two years alone; prices for businesses have gone up by a similar amount since 2022.”
At the core of the problem, says Mr Bridges, is a market structure that incentivises scarcity.
“The four gentailers maintain a stranglehold on the sector. Their combined retail market share is around 90%, and they control a similar proportion of the country’s generation capacity, including nearly all the firming (back-up) power.
“Scarcity of supply ensures elevated prices, and ensures that returns remain high across existing gentailer portfolios.”
Mr Bridges says gentailers are commercially incentivised to leverage their market power and vertically integrated structure to shut out new entrants and dampen competitive pressure.
“They can withhold access to firming for independent generators, whose projects cannot proceed without it. They invest just enough in new generation to stave off an immediate supply crisis, but not enough to put long-term downward pressure on prices.”
Mr Bridges says the so-called ‘renewables boom’ of the last 12-18 months has been more a case of gentailers catching up than getting ahead, and still falls well short of what is required.
The goal for the next government must be to turn this around, says Mr Bridges, and shift the dominant incentive from scarcity to abundance.
“Abundance is the key to energy affordability, energy security, and economic prosperity. We’d argue that reform of the energy market represents the most important opportunity the next government – and, perhaps, any government for a generation – will have to drive economic growth and lift living standards.”
Northern Infrastructure Forum Executive Director Barney Irvine says that while the development of a national energy strategy and operational separation of the gentailers have been well canvassed as policy responses, relatively few people will be familiar with the LTESA model.
“LTESAs are long-term contracts between a new-generation project and a Crown-backed entity, deployed to enable independent generators to bypass the firming barrier.
“Essentially, they act as an insurance product for independent generators: revenues can be topped up when wholesale prices are unusually low; support is paid back during unusually good revenue years.”
The concept is based on similar approaches in Australia.
Mr Irvine says the three policy initiatives have been chosen because they are complementary, can be implemented relatively quickly (i.e., within the new government’s first year) and will make a material difference.
“These measures alone won’t address all the sector’s problems, but they’re an ideal starting point,” he says.
“The case is compelling and the solution is clear. What is required now is action.”
Click here to view open letter.
About the NIF:
The NIF is a policy and advocacy organisation formed to help raise the standard of infrastructure planning and decision-making across the Upper North Island, and maximise the contribution that infrastructure can make to productivity and liveability.



